Dir: Alejandro Agresti
Writ: David Auburn
Jiro Asada(original Novella Siworae); Eun-Jeong Kim & Ji-na Yeo (writers of original film Siworae aka ]Il Mare)
- Keanu Reeves - Alex Wyler
- Sandra Bullock - Kate Forster
- Shohreh Aghdashloo - Anna Klyczynski
- Christopher Plummer - Simon Wyler
- Ebon Moss-Bachrach - Henry Wyler
- Willeke van Ammelrooy - Kate’s Mother
I didn’t think I’d enjoy this film. When I first heard about it I didn’t think I’d bother to go see, but then I read some reviews that persuaded me to check it out. I still didn’t think I’d enjoy it mind, but I thought I’d give it a go.
The basic plot revolves around a house, yes by a lake, hence The Lake House, and its mailbox. Which seems to be somesort of a time-portal type thing, allowing Kate and Alex to exchange letters. From a distance of two years. Kate is in 2006, Alex in 2004.
Despite my reservations there is actually quite a bit to like about this film. Reeves and Bullock have good chemistry, and the script has a lot of nice touches in the dialogue. However I didn’t like the way the letters the two characters were translated into total conversations, with one replying to a sentence and then the other responding as though they were able to talk in real time. It wasn’t a mysterious Instant Messaging time device they used. It was letters. But I was willing to over look that.
What I’m not willing to over look Show Spoilers ▼
is the ending. I’m not talking about figuring out that it was the Alex character that died in the first few minutes, I presume we are meant to be able to get that. No, what I’m talking about is the way changing something in the past causes an instant change in the present/future, which meant they could have the happy ending. I know, I know, we were given the hint about the tree planting. But the moment I saw that tree appear fully grown I was irked. If he planted it two years ago, then it
was. there. two. years. ago.
Rewritting history means that you rewrite it. It has happened. It is in the past. To future people that is all the history there is. Causality man! I feel like I’m in Star Trek and giving out about the time travel paradox.
So in the end I came out feeling annoyed. I’m glad I went, and overall it was a watchable film. But I didn’t like it.
IMDb | Official Site | Stainless Steel Droppings | Estella’s Revenge (scroll down) | Daring Young Mom |
Tags:
6 Stars,
Alejandro Agresti,
based on book,
Causality!,
Christopher Plummer,
David Auburn,
Ebon Moss-Bachrach,
Keanu Reeves,
romance,
Sandra Bullock,
sff,
Shohreh Aghdashloo,
The Lake House,
time travel,
Willeke van Ammelrooy
Related posts