Posts Tagged ‘poverty’

16
May

A Fine Balane

   Posted by: Fence   in Books

Image of A Fine BalanceAuthor: Rohinton Mistry
ISBN: 057123058x DDC: 813.54
See Also: LibraryThing ; Oprah’s Discussion ; BlogCritics ; Simon and Janet’s blog

Dina Dalal seldom indulged in looking back at her life with regret or bitterness, or questioning why things had turned out the way the way they had, cheating her of the bright future everyone had predicted for her when she was in school, when her name was still Dina Shroff.

I’m not really sure where to begin with this review. This is a big book, both in the amount of pages and in the amount of ground it covers. Set in an un-named city in India during the State of Emergency after India’s founding it deals with four main characters whose lives intersect in the house of Dina Dalal who hires two tailors and rents out a room to a young student in an attempt to keep her independence.

Each character gets a chance to backtrack and tell their story; Dina’s is one of love and then grief as her husband is killed in a road accident, and then of her desire to remain independent of her over-bearing older brother. Ishvar and Om are two Hindi tailors who have travelled to the city to make their fortune and escape the caste system of their home village. Maneck is the student lodger whose family lost much of their fortune during the Partition.

Read the rest of this entry »

Tags: 1970s, 813.54, 9 Stars, A Fine Balance, Booker Prize nominee, corruption, historical fiction, India, India - 1970s, Oprah pick, poverty, Rohinton Mistry, sterilization

Related posts

29
Jul

A Little Princess

   Posted by: Fence   in Moving Pictures

Dir: Alfonso Cuarón
Writ: Richard LaGravenese & Elizabeth Chandler, based on book by Frances Hodgson Burnett.

  • Liesel Matthews … Sara Crewe
  • Liam Cunningham … Capt. Crewe/Prince Rama
  • Vanessa Lee Chester … Becky
  • Eleanor Bron … Miss Minchin
  • Errol Sitahal … Ram Dass
  • Kelsey Mulrooney … Lottie

Sara Crewe lives a spoiled life in India with a devoted, doting father, until World War I intervenes, and he enlists, sending Sara off to boarding school in New York to keep her safe. There she must adjust, whereas before she had free rein to do as she pleased, now she must submit to rules and regulations that she doesn’t understand. And, most difficult for her, she must keep her imagination in check. But Sara isn’t a selfish, “poor little rich girl”, she is bright and kind, and soon makes friends with most of the other girls, from those in her class to the scullery maid. She is also the only one who can really get through to Lottie as they have both lost their mothers.

Read the rest of this entry »

Tags: A Little Princess, Alfonso Cuarón, awwww, based on book, childhood, Eleanor Bron, Elizabeth Chandler, Errol Sitahal, family film, Frances Hodgson Burnett, imagination, Kelsey Mulrooney, Liam Cunningham, Liesel Matthews, loss, New York, poverty, Richard LaGravenese, soldier, Vanessa Lee Chester, WWI

Related posts

18
Jan

The Pursuit of Happyness

   Posted by: Fence   in Moving Pictures

Dir: Gabriele Muccino
Writ: Steve Conrad

  • Will Smith - Chris Gardner
  • Jaden Smith - Christopher
  • Thandie Newton - Linda

Image Hosted by ImageShack.usAt the start of the film Linda is pulling double shifts while Chris is out selling bone density machines, struggling to make ends meet and support their young son Christopher. Things are not going well, the bone density machine isn’t selling as well as Chris had hoped and he had invested all his money in it. They are behind on the rent and nothing seems to be going their way. Their marriage too is under pressure and when Linda gets the offer of a job in New York she takes it, leaving Christopher behind with his father.

Chris, inspired to become a stoke-broker because he saw a shiny car, applies for an internship, and gets it, only to discover that it is unpaid.

He can’t pay the rent and is forced from his apartment to a motel, but can’t afford that and ends up spending the night in a train station, all the time trying to take care of his son. They move from homeless shelter to shelter, all the while Chris is trying to be the best intern at the stockbrokers, to be the one they offer a job to, all in the pursuit of happiness.

Acting-wise this is a good film. Will Smith has shown that he can handle more serious characters and is entirely believeable here. His son, Jaden plays his on scren son and is really fantastic. But I just couldn’t get behind the central messge of this film, which seemed to me to be “aim as high as you can, because if you try hard enough you will succeed and it will all be worth it”.

I don’t buy that.

What if there had been another intern in a similar position to our hero? One of them would have come away with nothing, and ended up on the streets, pursuing happiness is all well and good, but you have to deal in reality. We are constantly shown there happy ever after success stories, but what about all those people who go after this great prize only to fail? We don’t get to see their stories, yet surely their warnings are just as important as the rarer winners?

And then there is Chris’s message to his son, never let anyone tell you what you can’t do, never accept limits but find out what you want and go for it, don’t let anything stop you achieving it. Never let anyone tell you that you can’t do something.
Am I the only one a little disturbed by how selfish and stupid that message is?

IMDb | Blogcritics | Pajiba -Scathing reviews for bitchy people | Alas, A blog

Tags: 4 Stars, capitalism, film with a message, Gabriele Muccino, hope, Jaden Smith, meh, poverty, selfish, Steve Conrad, stupid, Thandie Newton, The Persuit of Happyness, Will Smith

Related posts