Ghosts of Vesuvius by

8 May 2011

Call no:
Genre: ,
Setting: ,
Rated :

Edited to add
Okay, so it turns out that Mr. Pellegrino is a more controversial author than I realised. His PhD may not in fact be real, his scientific claims may be incorrect. But I don’t know enough about Ancient Rome to ask the proper questions of his book…
Still, if you do read it, bear in mind that other people think he has gotten a lot of things wrong: Tess Gerritson on the myth of the author ; David Brennan on Fraud. This is what I get for doing research about an interesting book after I read it.

ghosts of vesuvius

Ghosts of Vesuvius - Charles Pellegrino

It is hard to blurb this book. On the one hand it is about Vesuvius and volcanic explosions and disasters both natural and man-made. But it is also a book about the origins of the earth, of the universe, and about how precarious our existence is. How so much of what we are today is dependent on natural events a thousand years ago, or a millennia ago, or so long ago that it is almost pointless to count the time because it is so difficult to grasp those sort of numbers.

I have seen it called a Metalogue and I have to agree with that definition, a text or conversation in which the form resembles the content.

I’m not sure what I expected of this book. I picked up based on the recommendation of someone or other on a library-related work “how to” forum. The cover made me assume it was about Pompeii. But then I read “a new look at the last days of Pompeii, how towers fall, and other strange connections” and I figured that the best thing to do was just start reading and hope it was entertaining.

Well, I’m not sure if entertaining is the right word. When talking about disasters on such a huge scale it seems wrong somehow to describe a book as entertaining. But it was certainly informative. It is a narrative history, with science and religion and philosophy all mixed in there as well. It is extremely well-written, but it has a style all of its own. In a way it is sort of stream of consciousness. And on occasions it is slightly repetitive, but that is a deliberate decision, or at least, that is how it comes across. Some readers might say it rambles all over the place, and it does, but at the same time it has a very important message at its heart. We have very little control over our lives, over the world, and for all our scientific achievement and progress, we are still dependent on the earth’s stability and that cannot be guaranteed, because, over the long-haul the earth is not static. It is a constantly changing, constantly shifting entity.

It is a personal account as well, and for that reason I cannot be too critical of what I found was too much time spent covering individual tales of survival at the World Trade Centre attacks. Some of it was incredibly well told and moving, but reading one story after another in such a manner made these extraordinary events somehow mundane, in my opinion.

ISBN: 9780060751005 Other reviews: Frances Kakugawa’s blog ; Steve reads ; Mixed Meters

You may also like...

2 Responses

  1. Caroline says:

    I was in Pompeii and it is a strange experience. Those imprints of bodies, frozen in time. As if they were still running away. There was alos a little dog. Too bad he added to many 9/11 stories. I can see how the repetition could weaken it.
    Caroline´s last blog post ..Gianrico Carofiglio- Involuntary Witness aka Testimone inconsapevole 2002 First in an Italian Legal Thriller Series

    • Fence says:

      I'd say it is strange. It is amazing the damage the earth can do. Just watched a programme on the telly about Thera, which is mentioned in Ghosts of Vesuvius, a much more powerful earthquake in the Bronze Age.