Filed Under: Books

Myths about suicide by

Genre:

ISBN: 9780674048225

Across human history and across cultures, what has been the most stigmatized of human behaviors?

What do you think when you hear that someone has committed suicide? Many probably wonder why? and then begin to speculate. Some will accuse the suicide victim of being selfish, or cowardly and not being able to live. But for Joiner these responses are not answers. They are myths. He has researched this topic at great lengths, and he also has personal experience, as his father committed suicide. As did his maternal grandfather. In this book he lists the main myths that people use to try and explain suicide, and then he debunks them.

This was a really fascinating book. If a morbid one. It is the sort of book I think I only would have come across working where I do, in a public library, where we get all sorts of books.

myths about suicide

Myths about suicide - Thomas Joiner

It did take me a long while to read. Once reason is that I was only reading it at lunch time, which is not the book’s issue. The other reason is that it is a non-fiction book on a serious topic, which means I was always going to read it at a slower pace. But honestly, while the topic is of course morbid, this is not a morbid book. Sure, it deals with death, but it is a lot more concerned with helping people. Both those who might be suicidal and those people who have to deal with losing someone to suicide. Because suicide carries with it a stigma that makes it an additional burden for thoe left behind. There can often be guilt, why didn’t I do something to stop this person committing suicide, not to mention anger and bitterness at the person who died. Joiner is at great pains to point out that he doesn’t believe that suicide is ever really a selfish choice. He argues that almost everyone who commits suicide does so after a mental break that means they see the world as being a better place without them. They do not see how their presence is of benefit to anyone, indeed theu often see it as detrimental to their loved ones.

He also argues, most strenously, for investment in barriers on bridges. The belief that if someone really wants to commit suicide then they will find a way is a “myth” he does not agree with. Instead he argues that preventing someone in the short-term can often lead to them reconsidering their actions and not actually committing suicide.

But I’m not about to list and explain all the myths that Joiner sees in today’s culture. I’ll just advise to you to read the book. On occasion Joiner comes across as a little too “I’m right” for my liking. He states things as though they were hard fact, when in reality, we don’t know. But at the same time, he always offers evidence for why he belives what he believes. And he writes with a great deal of sensitivity.

Surprisingly highly recommended.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

6 Comments

  • 22 October 2010 - 1:11 am | Permalink

    Fence, I am SO happy to see this book, and equally happy that you're recommending it. It bugs me every time I hear someone talk about how 'selfish' it is for this person or that to have committed suicide, when truly, selfishness has nothing to do with it. The person has just come to the end of their resources; they truly can't cope any longer. It sounds as if the author has gone a long way toward encouraging more compassion than judgment for these poor souls. My heart goes out to them. I'm going to look for the book!
    Kelly´s last blog post ..Yo ho ho and a bottle of rum &amp coke
    Kelly´s last blog post ..Yo ho ho and a bottle of rum &amp coke

    • 23 October 2010 - 4:21 pm | Permalink

      I won't say enjoy, because it isn't that sort of a book, but it is one that I found had a lot of really interesting points to make.

  • 22 October 2010 - 2:06 am | Permalink

    Definitely an odd topic, but it sounds like a really interesting book! Thanks for the review.
    Amy´s last blog post ..Review- No Place Left to Bury the Dead by Nicole Itano
    Amy´s last blog post ..Review- No Place Left to Bury the Dead by Nicole Itano

    • 23 October 2010 - 4:22 pm | Permalink

      Not my usual sort of a read, that is for sure :)

  • 24 October 2010 - 1:23 pm | Permalink

    Did you read 13 Reasons Why, the YA book by Jay Asher? Fanstatic. 13 Reasons why a young girls commots suicide, meaning 13 ways people let her down. Funny enough it is not a sad book. For really sad reasons this is a topic I have always been interested in. For weird reasons we have a huge number of suicides in my family. There are so many reasons why a person would take his/her life. Rasing awareness is so important. Thanks for this review.
    Caroline´s last blog post ..Daniel Glattauer- Love Virtually 2011 aka Gut gegen Nordwind 2006 A German Novel in E-Mails
    Caroline´s last blog post ..Daniel Glattauer- Love Virtually 2011 aka Gut gegen Nordwind 2006 A German Novel in E-Mails

    • 24 October 2010 - 6:41 pm | Permalink

      I hadn't even heard of it till you mentioned it, but now I'll have to keep an eye out for it.

  • Comments are closed.

    Powered by: Wordpress